AD2000 - a journal of religious opinionAD Books
Ask a Question
View Cart
Search AD2000: author: full text:  
AD2000 - a journal of religious opinion
Find a Book:

AD2000 Home
Article Index
About AD2000
Contact Us
Email Updates


Add Me
Remove Me

Subscriber Access:

Enter the Internet Access Key from your mailing label here for full access!


Catholic religious education: some grassroots views

Bookmark and Share

 Contents - Jun 2011AD2000 June 2011 - Buy a copy now
Homily: The Meaning of Jesus' Ascension - Benedict XVI
Why Pope Benedict removed Toowoomba's dissenting bishop - Michael Gilchrist
Australia's Anglican Ordinariate on track - Bishop Peter Elliott
News: The Church Around the World
Redefining gender: an assault on human dignity - Babette Francis
Archbishop Hickey: tribute to an outstanding Church leader - Brian Peachey
Australia's seminary numbers continue to increase - Br Barry Coldrey
Cardinal Pell: 'liberalism has no young Catholic progeny' - Cardinal George Pell
Events: St Thomas More: still A Man for all Seasons - Emma O'Shea
Letters: Catholic religious education: some grassroots views - John Morissey
Moral values and the march of science - Archbishop Charles J. Chaput
Letters: Greens' agenda - Peter Finlayson
Letters: Climate change - R. Blackstock
Letters: North Africa - Andrew Sholl
Letters: Mark Twain - Fr. F.E. Burns
Letters: Challenge - Fr. Bernard McGrath
Books: JESUS OF NAZARETH: Holy Week, by Pope Benedict XVI - Fr Glen Tattersall FSSP (reviewer)
Books: THE STORY OF THE LITURGY IN IRELAND, by Edmond Gerard Cullinan - Michael E Daniel (reviewer)
Books: MARRIAGE: The Rock on Which the Family is Built, by William E. May - Br Barry Coldrey (reviewer)
Books: HEART OF THE CHRISTIAN LIFE: Thoughts on Holy Mass, by Pope Benedict XVI - Michael Daniel (reviewer)
Events: Australian Confraternity of Catholic Clergy 25th Anniversary
Events: Public Lecture - The Catholic Gift to Civilisation - Rev Fr Marcus Holden
Books: Order books from
Reflection: Pentecost, the feast of true hope for humanity - Bishop Arthur Serratelli

A forum on Catholic religious education was conducted at the St Leonard's parish centre, Glen Waverley, in the Melbourne Archdiocese in early April. With about 50-60 people in attendance, it was addressed by Bishop Peter Elliott, Episcopal Vicar for Religious Education, before being thrown open to questions and statements from the floor.

I attended as an observer because I am vitally interested in the subject and have gained some perspective while teaching in State, Catholic, Protestant and Jewish schools over many years.

The Bishop outlined the many positive developments in Catholic religious education, pointing to the mandated texts, To Know, Worship and Love, which were prepared and published under his direction, the training of teachers at the Australian Catholic University, and the new staff college for Catholic principals to be opened in East Melbourne. Religious education, he assured the meeting, was alive and well at many Catholic schools, especially the primary schools where a number of excellent RECs (religious education co-ordinators) were in place.

Situation in practice

When questions were invited from the floor, however, many grievances were expressed against what is offered in practice as religious education in our Catholic schools. Some parents attributed their children's giving up practice of their religion to their experience in Catholic schools, while others even reported that their younger children, whom they had shifted to state or independent schools, were retaining their Faith.

Many abuses were alleged, principally a failure to teach the basics of the Faith and misrepresentation or ridicule of some Catholic teachings. A number of home-schoolers spoke, and all justified their decision to home-school as concern for their children's Catholic faith.

Bishop Elliott listened to all of their grievances and expressed his sympathy and support, undertaking to look into any real abuses which could be substantiated. He agreed that the problem lies in the attitude of some teachers in the schools who undermine Catholic beliefs and practices.

He also stressed the duty and the right of parish priests to monitor religious education in our primary schools and also mentioned the vapid songs which pass for hymns in our schools, of the "Share in the bread, share in the wine" variety, which do nothing for children's understanding of Catholic doctrine or spirituality.

The parish priest, Fr Brendan Dillon, challenged the homeschoolers, arguing that children from solid Catholic families are needed in our schools as a leavening and example for those who are non-practising or more casual in their observance. This is a reasonable argument, but who can blame the passionate response from some home-schoolers present, seeing the souls of their own children as their first concern?

I have nothing but gratitude for the heroic teaching sisters and brothers who in the 1950s and 1960s instilled the Faith in us, with the catechism, prayer, an understanding of the liturgy and the sacraments, and hymns which reflected orthodox Church teaching.

This formation contrasts with what I have witnessed in several stints in Catholic secondary schools in the past decade, where religious education has been superficial, if not hostile to Church teaching, and faith development has been insipid. A school Mass is described as a "Eucharist", and the less said the better about preparation for receiving Communion.

New age mysticism and a pantheistic approach to Divine Revelation have also been evident, while traditional Catholic images have been banished from classrooms. It is not uncommon to find the Faith ridiculed: witness the recent "Passion Play" (proudly exhibited on YouTube) as performed at a Victorian Catholic regional college, which pauses from buffoonery only for blasphemy.

Presbyterian example

For much of the past eight years I have taught at Presbyterian Ladies College, and what I have experienced there puts to shame many of our Catholic secondary schools. At PLC religious education is largely Scripture-based and quite unapologetic, in spite of the diversity of religions among the students.

Every Protestant denomination is represented, along with a sprinkling of Catholics and Muslims, and a sizeable number of Buddhists, Hindus and even non-believers. All students attend and treat with respect their Christian Studies classes and the general assemblies, which have a profound religious component.

Preparation for Easter this year could not have impressed me more. Normally, a general assembly includes two hymns, sung by students and staff, a Scripture reading and prayer, but each morning that week was special. First came a homily on friendship from the school's ordained chaplain, and he took as his text "Greater love has no man than this, that a man lay down his life for his friends" (John 15:13). There followed an exquisite "Panis Angelicus" sung by one of the school's several choirs.

On the second day the Christian Studies co-ordinator gave an illustrated talk on the religious significance of the many symbols of the Easter season while on the third day a student read a long Gospel account of the Passion and Resurrection.

On the last day the principal conducted a quiz show. Three senior students answered questions based on the previous day's Gospel and general knowledge about Easter, to the enthusiastic applause of their school-mates.

Of course, much of this strength comes from the families, and many of the girls come from intensely religious ones, including those from Catholic families who have chosen PLC, knowing that their daughters' faith and religious identity are in no danger there, and that parents can "top up" at home. Unfortunately, it is two generations since Catholic parents could entrust this duty to most of our schools.

Bookmark and Share

Reprinted from AD2000 Vol 24 No 5 (June 2011), p. 11

Page design and automation by
Umbria Associates Pty Ltd © 2001-2004