AD2000 - a journal of religious opinionAD Books
Ask a Question
View Cart
Search AD2000: author: full text:  
AD2000 - a journal of religious opinion
Find a Book:

AD2000 Home
Article Index
About AD2000
Contact Us
Email Updates


Add Me
Remove Me

Subscriber Access:

Enter the Internet Access Key from your mailing label here for full access!

Priestly Identity

Renewing the priesthood in the Year for Priests

Bookmark and Share

 Contents - Oct 2009AD2000 October 2009 - Buy a copy now
Editorial: Anglican Communion's moment of truth - Michael Gilchrist
Priestly Identity: Renewing the priesthood in the Year for Priests - Fr Anthony Denton
News: The Church Around the World
Community Life: 'Progressive' leadership and the demise of religious life - Br Paul Macrossan
Youth: RISE: restoring integrity and sexual ethics to Australia's secular culture - Br Barry Coldrey
Episcopacy: Bishop Luc Matthys: on being a bishop - Bishop Luc Matthys of Armidale
Poetry: A Morning Poem - Bruce Dawe
Seminary Life: Spiritual direction at Sydney's Good Shepherd Seminary - Fr Paul Glynn SM
FOUNDATIONS OF FAITH: Cutting edge moral issues for the third millennium - Br Barry Coldrey
Priesthood: Why the Catholic Church cannot ordain women - Kathleen Wood OAM
Letters: Liturgy reform - Paul Martin
Letters: Healthy families - John Carty
Letters: Marriage and divorce - Arnold Jago
Letters: Christian divisions - Jack Blair
Letters: Galileo debate - David Walker
Letters: Prayer for Priests - John Schmid
Letters: Thanks from India - Fr. S. John Joseph
Books: THE QUEST FOR SHAKESPEARE, by Joseph Pearce - Michael Daniel (reviewer)
Books: THE CASE FOR CHRISTIANITY: St Justin Martyr on Religious Liberty, Robert Haddad - Br Michael McMurray CCS
Books: AFTER THE HEART OF GOD, by Bishop Julian Porteous - Br Michael McMurray CCS (reviewer)
Update: The 2009 Fighting Fund
Books: This month's selection from AD Books
Reflection: The Mass: priest and people offer sacrifice - Bishop Edward Slattery

Given that most Catholics experience the Church through involvement in their parish, anything which affects priests has ramifications for parishes and therefore for parishioners.

The wholesale secularisation of once-Christian Australian society has affected the Church and given rise to the current precarious state of Catholic life and practice. While confusion rages in many minds about the true nature of the liturgy, and the effects of the clerical abuse scandals continue to be felt, vocations have declined and Catholic schools have floundered in their task of transmitting the faith.

Into this situation have come the positive effects of the Pontificate of John Paul II with a prodigious output of papal teaching on topics that most effect the day to day belief of Catholics: the Eucharist, the sacrament of Penance, the centrality of faith in Christ, the meaning of suffering, to name but a few. His writings on the priesthood have been both personal and profound.

A particularly hopeful aspect of Pope John Paul II's pontificate was his outreach to youth. His indomitable faith in God and in young people has been continued in the pontificate of his long-time collaborator and friend Joseph Ratzinger as Pope Benedict XVI.

Priestly identity

One of Pope John Paul II's tasks had been to tackle the crisis in priestly identity that emerged out of the cultural morass of the 1970s and 80s.

There is ample evidence of a systematic and deliberate move to change the Church's theology of priesthood. Cardinal Avery Dulles names three theologians in particular who had great influence in the post-conciliar period. Hans Küng, Leonardo Boff and Edward Schillebeeckx broke with the constant teaching of the Church when they knocked out a central pillar of the Church's theology of priesthood, rejecting "the ontological understanding of the priestly character".

Many people (including many priests) have been led astray by the false teaching of these prominent and influential theologians. We have all, no doubt, heard comments to the effect that a priest used to be placed on a pedestal, but now we know he is just like everyone else. It was reasoned that a priest no longer receives an indelible mark on his soul at ordination, or more precisely, that no priest ever did.

The conclusion reached by many was that the Church perpetuated the myth to keep power in the hands of a few. The result of such positions is explained by Fr Benedict Groeschel: "This kind of thinking has done much harm to several aspects of Catholic life and in this case has been an important undermining factor in the decrease and loss of priestly vocations." Clearly, this is a matter of no small importance.

Human dimension

St John Vianney famously described the Catholic priesthood as "the love of the heart of Jesus." By this he meant that a priest is a reflection of Jesus' love, symbolised by his sacred, human heart. As Fr George Rutler explains, "The love of a priest is the unbounded love of the priest for his priesthood".

One of the most important evolutions in tridentine seminary formation has been the recognition that all aspects of formation are built upon the human dimension. Affective maturity enables a man to give due expression to what he has gained from his spiritual, pastoral and intellectual formation.

Perhaps the point is made more clearly according to the via negativa. When a man is seriously lacking in affective maturity the results can be disastrous. In the arduous task of growing in virtue one of the great helps is the nurturing of healthy relationships.

Families can be enriched in extraordinary ways by a son or brother who is a priest; but for the priest himself, parents, siblings, nieces and nephews become even more important. They can provide stability and a safe haven where he can relax. In my experience they also are prepared to keep him honest in a way that is non-threatening!

Other important relationships are those with fellow priests who are the only ones who really know what it is like to be a priest; with families who can teach patience and love; and with personal friends either from the past or from the cultural or sporting interests that he may have.

The situation in modern presbyteries in Australia (and most Western countries, I've discovered) finds the priest living alone with a minimum of domestic support.

It is said of the Cure of Ars that after hearing the confessions of thousands of priests over his lifetime, he was convinced that they should not live alone. There are many reasons why this might be the case. Besides the obvious issue of loneliness I think the real problem is that a priest risks acquiring the very thing that his celibacy is meant to dissuade: selfishness.

The most common solution offered to solve this dilemma has been the call for priests to be able to marry. This non-solution (for too many reasons to go into here) has meant that the real issue at hand has been dismissed instead of being addressed seriously and creatively.

Pope Benedict cites the Cure's observation: "A good shepherd, a pastor after God's heart, is the greatest treasure which the good Lord can grant to a parish, and one of the most precious gifts of divine mercy."

This article is adapted from Fr Anthony Denton's address at the launch of Bishop Julian Porteous' new book, 'After the Heart of God: The Life and Ministry of Priests at the Beginning of the Third Millennium'. This book is reviewed on page 17.

Fr Denton is the Director of Vocations for the Archdiocese of Melbourne.

Bookmark and Share

Reprinted from AD2000 Vol 22 No 9 (October 2009), p. 3

Page design and automation by
Umbria Associates Pty Ltd © 2001-2004