AD2000 - a journal of religious opinionAD Books
Ask a Question
View Cart
Search AD2000: author: full text:  
AD2000 - a journal of religious opinion
Find a Book:

AD2000 Home
Article Index
About AD2000
Contact Us
Email Updates


Add Me
Remove Me

Subscriber Access:

Enter the Internet Access Key from your mailing label here for full access!

Liturgical Time Bombs In Vatican II, by Michael Davies

Bookmark and Share

 Contents - Oct 2003AD2000 October 2003 - Buy a copy now
Editorial: The role of the Catholic in public life - Peter Westmore
After 25 years: the impact of John Paul II's pontificate - Michael Gilchrist
News: The Church Around the World - AD2000
Ethics: Bishop Fisher and Dr Philip Nitschke in Sydney euthanasia debate - Frank Mobbs
Saints: The Beatification of Mother Teresa of Calcutta
Youth: Thomas More Winter School in Sale Diocese has Eucharistic focus - Michael Casanova
Melbourne Archdiocese responds to John Paul II's Year of the Rosary - AD2000 Report
How fatherhood is crucial to children's faith - Fr Robbie Low
Why Catholic teaching on marriage is 'good news' for all humanity - Eamonn Keane
AD2000 readers' generous response to Queensland Lourdes appeal - Jenny Davies and Nicole King
Orthodox US Catholic colleges and universities continue to flourish - Julia Duin
Letters: Original Sin (letter) - Niall Browne
Letters: Individual confession (letter) - John Cassar
Letters: Clerical celibacy (letter) - Gerard Wilson
Letters: New bishops (letter) - Anne Lastman
Letters: Thomas Groome (letter) - Dr Susan Moore
Letters: Education crisis (letter) - Alex Sharah
Letters: New RE program (letter) - Paul Chigwidden
Letters: Inspiring hymn (letter) - Kevin O'Hagan
Letters: Footy Show (letter) - Alan A. Hoysted
Books: I The Lord Am With You Always: Prayers and Meditations for Eucharistic Adoration - Msgr Peter J. Elliott (reviewer)
Liturgical Time Bombs In Vatican II, by Michael Davies - Michael Gilchrist (reviewer)
Books: Crisis In Religious Education, by Eamonn Keane - Damien Tudehope (reviewer)
Books: Great books at the best prices!
Reflection: Why the tabernacle should be centrally located in our churches - Fr Sebastian Camilleri OFM

by Michael Davies

(Tan Books, 2003, 117pp, $20.00 plus $1.25 postage. Available from Saint Benedict Book Centre, PO Box 100, Bunyip, Vic 3815, (03) 5629-6247, fax (03) 5629-6248; also from AD Books)

Those familiar with Michael Davies' prolific writings on changes in the Catholic Liturgy since Vatican II will need no introduction to the present work. Its subtitle - "The destruction of Catholic faith through changes in Catholic worship" - says it all.

Liturgical Time Bombs is basically an updated summary of Davies' main arguments expressed in his earlier and comprehensive three-volume series Liturgical Revolution published in the 1980s. Through this abbreviated presentation, it is no doubt hoped more readers will have access to the issues Davies discusses.

Davies' analysis will certainly come as a shock to those Catholics who remain unaware of the contentious matters he raises and would no doubt be rejected out of hand by those committed to what has passed for "renewal" in the name of Vatican II. Elsewhere, "denial" in high places has sometimes been the order of the day, along with an understandable reluctance by the orthodox to admit that anything officially sanctioned by the Church could have been poorly managed.

Archbishop Bugnini

At the centre of Davies' analysis is the role of the late Archbishop Annibale Bugnini as the chief architect of the liturgical "revolution" that ultimately went well beyond the expectations of most Council Fathers.

Archbishop Bugnini and his supporters who helped draw up the Vatican II Liturgy Constitution were able to produce a document that was conservative and reassuring in many respects - with its calls for the retention of Latin, Gregorian chant and the like - while containing assorted ambiguously-worded "time bombs".

In the hands of radical liturgists charged with implementing the Council document in the late 1960s, these "time bombs", involving such considerations as "participation", "inculturation" or use of the vernacular, could be used to justify all manner of major changes never dreamt of by most bishops who voted for the Liturgy Constitution.

Davies draws on the assessments of many highly qualified people to bolster his case, e.g., Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger and Msgr Klaus Gamber. Another is the late Cardinal Heenan, former Archbishop of Westminster, who was one of the thousands of bishops present at the Council. He followed developments during and after Vatican II closely and at times with much concern. His views on the way things were headed would prove prophetic.

Davies writes: "Cardinal Heenan was present in the Sistine Chapel for Father Bugnini's demonstration of his newly concocted experimental rite of Mass in 1967 (Missa Normativa), and he was dismayed by what he witnessed. He commented: 'At home it is not only women and children but also fathers of families and young men who come regularly to Mass. If we were to offer them the kind of ceremony we saw yesterday in the Sistine Chapel we would soon be left with a congregation mostly of women and children."

The Cardinal's prophecy would be confirmed. Thirty years later, a working paper for the 1999 Synod of European Bishops in Rome commented on responses received from bishops in the pre-synodal survey: "In most countries of the West, liturgical celebrations are frequented almost exclusively by children and older people, especially women. The young and middle-aged are few in number. Such a situation runs the risk of projecting an image of a Church which is only for the elderly, women and children."

Impact of changes

Admittedly, one needs to be wary of the post hoc, propter hoc logical fallacy in assessing the impact of post-Vatican II liturgical changes. But it is undeniable that aspects of these changes were unwarranted in terms of Vatican II's clear wordings. Moreover, they have weakened many lay people's sense of the sacred, perception of the priest as in persona Christi and awareness of the real presence in the Eucharist.

The huge fallaway in Mass attendances in Western countries like Australia and the US since the late 1960s can be attributed to a number of factors, not least the weakening of family structures (with so many absent fathers), the "cultural revolution" and the increasing impact of the secular mass media. One might also add, defective catechesis.

Nevertheless, keeping in mind the principle of lex orandi, lex credendi (how we worship is how we will believe), some aspects of the modern Liturgy have undeniably made a difficult situation worse - at least in Western countries.

The situation in Asia, Africa and Latin America - where religious sentiments have been less eroded by secularism or other factors such as nationalism are at work - is often different with some of the liturgical changes having a more positive impact. Davies does not investigate this area, confining himself mostly to the precarious position of the Faith in Western countries.

Fortunately, many in high places in the Church - including Rome - are showing an increasing awareness of the liturgical problems that Davies pinpoints. The Pope's recent encyclical on the Eucharist - which Davies quotes from - is a case in point.

This is an important little book and deserves a wide readership. More people need to be aware of the problems and their possible causes if we are to undo the harm done to the Liturgy over the past 40 years - often in the name of Vatican II renewal. Not all will agree with Davies' assessments, but his views deserve mature, informed consideration.

Bookmark and Share

Reprinted from AD2000 Vol 16 No 9 (October 2003), p. 16

Page design and automation by
Umbria Associates Pty Ltd © 2001-2004