AD2000 - a journal of religious opinionAD Books
Ask a Question
View Cart
Search AD2000: author: full text:  
AD2000 - a journal of religious opinion
Find a Book:

AD2000 Home
Article Index
About AD2000
Contact Us
Email Updates


Add Me
Remove Me

Subscriber Access:

Enter the Internet Access Key from your mailing label here for full access!

Power without responsibility: the vendetta against Dr Pell

Bookmark and Share

 Contents - Oct 2002AD2000 October 2002 - Buy a copy now
Editorial: Positive developments in liturgy - Michael Gilchrist
Power without responsibility: the vendetta against Dr Pell - Peter Westmore
News: The Church Around the World - AD2000
Commission for Australian Catholic Women justifies its existence - Michael Gilchrist
Liturgy: Vatican control over ICEL tightens - Dr William Oddie
Bishop Power: Church teachings need to be 're-examined' - AD2000 REPORT
US billionaire promotes orthodox teaching - Zenit News Service
Catholic liturgy in the 21st century: major challenges facing the Church - Fr Peter Williams
John Henry Newman's critique of liberalism - Michael Davies
Letters: Archbishop Pell (letter) - Eamonn & Patricia Keane
Letters: "The Pell Show" (letter) - Stephen Hitchings
Letters: Justice? (letter) - Godwin Brown
Letters: Shepherds (letter) - Br Con Moloney CFC
Letters: Church "renovation" (letter) - B. Tooley
Letters: Church re-design (letter) - Michael Barry
Letters: Soul and body (letter) - Dr Nicholas Tonti-Filippini
Letters: Zero tolerance (letter) - Alan A. Hoysted
Letters: Letters to the Bishops (letter) - Mavis Power
Letters: Catholic education (letter) - Dr Garrick Small
Letters: US theologians (letter) - Fr G.H. Duggan SM
Letters: Celibate priesthood (letter) - Cyril Drew
Letters: Good response (letter) - C.G. Jarrells
Letters: Novus Ordo (letter) - Maurice Collins
Letters: New Zealand (letter) - Kevin E. Fennessy
Poetry: The Great Deliverance - Marion Craig
Books: The Courage to be Catholic, by George Weigel - Michael Novak (reviewer)
Books: Completed Jew, by Andrew Sholl - Michael Casanova (reviewer)
Books: Godfaring: On Reason, Faith and Sacred Being, by Francis Clark - Br Christian Moe FSC (reviewer)
Books: New Titles from AD Books
Reflection: Devotion to God through the Angelus and Rosary - Fr Fabian Duggan OSB

The decision by the Melbourne Age to publish allegations by an unnamed person, concerning improper conduct over 40 years ago by Archbishop George Pell, when he was a 19-year-old seminarian in Melbourne, highlights a very dangerous trend in Australian society: the power of sections of the media to aggressively impugn the good reputation of a distinguished person on the basis of mere assertion.

This has been particularly so in the case of Dr Pell, whose unambiguous defence of Catholic and Christian values stands in stark contrast to the apparent moral agenda of the pro-libertarian secular media.

The Archbishop rejected the allegations, calling them "lies", but announced that he would step aside, pending an independent inquiry, "for the good of the Church and to preserve the dignity of the office of Archbishop".

Any person who is aware of the pioneering role which Dr Pell played, after his appointment as Archbishop of Melbourne, in ensuring that the Catholic Church fully and fairly addresses accusations of sexual misconduct by clergy and religious would find the content of the allegations most improbable.

A fellow student who attended the Melbourne seminary at the time dismissed the allegations as "ridiculous" and "inconceivable", and told me that that Dr Pell was an exemplary seminarian.

This, clearly, was the view of the seminary staff and his own bishop, who sent him to Propaganda Fide College in Rome, where he completed his studies for the priesthood before his ordination in St Peter's Basilica in 1966.

In all the time he was a student, a seminarian, a parish priest, Director of the Aquinas Campus of the Institute of Catholic Education from 1974-84 and as Principal of the Institute of Catholic Education (now part of Australian Catholic University), auxiliary bishop and Archbishop of Melbourne, there has never been an allegation of any sort of impropriety against him, of the type now made, or otherwise.

The same point was made by the President of the Australian Council for Civil Liberties, Terry O'Gorman, in an interview on the ABC's The World Today on 21 August.

Mr O'Gorman, who made clear he completely disagreed with positions which Archbishop Pell had taken on issues such as homosexuality, embryo research and abortion, said, "It used to be the law in Australia, before we became just absolutely hysterical and unbalanced about the procedures in relation to investigating child sex accusations, that a person wouldn't be named unless a person was actually charged.

"So far have we gone down the road of trashing a presumption of innocence that a law change is called for to restore, and to restore fundamentally, the principles of presumption of innocence."

Yet the Melbourne Age and its stable-mate, the Sydney Morning Herald, both published, in graphic detail, disgusting allegations made by their informant against Archbishop Pell, while protecting the anonymity of the informant, and admitting that he had no corroborating evidence to back up his allegations.

Distorted reports

The present allegations have followed earlier media stories implying that the Archbishop was soft on child sexual abuse.

The most recent of these followed comments Dr Pell made at the World Youth Day in Toronto, when at the end of a 40 minute talk, he was asked a question about what young Catholics should say when they are asked about sexual abuse in the Church. In the face of subsequent distorted media reports, the Archbishop offered the following account of what he actually said.

Clerical sexual abuse, he told his Toronto audience, was "an enormous moral scandal that has caused great damage to the victims and their families, and also to the Church. We have to be aware of this problem, face it honestly and deal with it in a just, compassionate, and effective way.

"I went on to state that there are other grave moral scandals in society, which receive little media coverage. Abortion would be a prime example.

"I accept that many people do not share our view on this issue, but for Christians abortion represents the destruction of innocent human life.

"There are many terrible wrongs that people can suffer, often with life-long consequences. But Christian teaching is at one with the law and secular ethics in holding that the supreme wrong that can be done to a person is the taking of his or her life. This claim does not make any other evils less evil.

"This was the context in which my remarks were made and in which they should be understood. My words did not in anyway downplay the seriousness of sexual abuse. At the end of the session I was given a standing ovation, as reported in the Canadian press, but not by the Australian media. My young listeners agreed with me. Sexual abuse is evil, but there are other serious evils in society as well.

"Where innocent or vulnerable people are hurt, honesty and compassion are essential. The Church has accepted the challenge to respond in this way to sexual abuse. It is important that our community should do the same on the issue of abortion."

An earlier controversy involved a Sixty Minutes interview last June by Richard Carleton, which alleged the Archbishop had approved payment of "hush money" to sex abuse victims.

A prominent Australian columnist, Frank Devine, wrote recently that nothing that went to air more clearly demonstrated Sixty Minutes' single-minded purpose than Carleton's "faking" [of Dr Pell's] relationship with a notorious Ballarat paedophile priest, Gerard Ridsdale (Quadrant, September 2002).

He added, "What followed over the next two weeks, emanating from nearly all media, was an outburst of malice and foolishness that calls for a novelist's attention."

Whatever the damage these allegations have done, Archbishop Pell remains the outstanding religious leader in Australia today, because he refuses to be intimidated by those who wish to destroy him. Archbishop Pell has our unqualified support.

Bookmark and Share

Reprinted from AD2000 Vol 15 No 9 (October 2002), p. 3

Page design and automation by
Umbria Associates Pty Ltd © 2001-2004